AU2005262278A1

AU2005262278A1 - A device for distributed maximum power tracking for solar arrays

Info

Publication number: AU2005262278A1
Application number: AU2005262278A
Authority: AU
Inventors: Peter Wolfs
Original assignee: Queensland State Department of Public Works; Central Queensland University
Current assignee: Tigo Energy Inc
Priority date: 2004-07-13
Filing date: 2005-07-12
Publication date: 2006-01-19
Anticipated expiration: 2025-07-12
Also published as: AU2005262278B2

Description

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 A DEVICE FOR DISTRIBUTED MAXIMUM POWER TRACKING FOR SOLAR ARRAYS FIELD OF INVENTION The present invention relates to solar cell technology and in particular to maximum power tracking converters. The present invention has particular but not exclusive application for use in vehicles that are at least in part electrically powered by solar cells. Reference to solar powered vehicles is by means of example only and the present invention has application in other areas. BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION A solar cell is a device able to convert incident light to electrical power. Many solar cells are typically grouped to form an array of solar cells. To collect the electrical power from the solar cells, groups of cells are either directly connected in series or in parallel. Where the cells are connected in series, they must have identical currents but if the cells are connected in parallel they must operate with identical voltages. An individual cell will produce maximum power at a unique cell voltage and current which will vary from cell to cell. The combination of voltage and current that allows a cell to produce its maximum power is termed the maximum power point. The maximum power point varies with cell illumination and temperature. Connection of the cells in series forces cells to have identical current while connection in parallel forces cells to have identical voltage. Direct connection in series or parallel results in failure to collect all the available electrical power from the solar cells in the array and at least some of the cells will operate at a condition other than at their maximum power points.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -2 To obtain the maximum available power from a group of solar cells connected in an array or sub-array, a maximum power tracking device is used. Maximum power tracking devices are DC to DC power converters that allow an array or sub array to operate at their maximum power point. A DC to DC converter can transform 5 a power input at a certain voltage and current to be transformed to a DC power output at a differing voltage and current. A key feature of all maximum power trackers is a control device that determines the point of maximum power for the connected solar cells and acts to adjust the DC to DC converter performance to adjust the cell voltage or current to extract the maximum available power. 10 However there are a number of problems or disadvantages associated with the use of a single maximum power device to control the voltage or current of an array or sub-array of solar cells. Where solar cells are used to power vehicles, the vehicles are usually aerodynamically designed with curved surfaces and also have limited surface area in 15 which to mount the solar cells. Consequently arrays of cells are mounted on the curved surfaces but the variation of the angle of incidence of light on the different cells within the array on the curved surface causes variation in the available optical power. Furthermore, cells in an array may be subjected to variable light levels due to shadowing by foreign objects such as trees and buildings between the cell and the 20 source of illumination. Because of differences in optical illumination, cell temperatures may vary within arrays causing some cells to be hotter than other cells. Arrays may be cooled partially by air flow or by the use of a cooling fluid in an illumination concentrator system. These mechanisms however may not provide uniform cooling to all cells.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -3 The available power from each cell within an array will vary due to the variations in illumination and temperature. In these cases, the maximum power conditions of different cells within the array will differ at any one point of time. Furthermore the maximum power conditions of some cells within the array will vary 5 differently over time compared with others. As well these variations are not predictable. In addition changes to the maximum power conditions of cells can vary rapidly thereby requiring a relatively quick response time. Currently maximum power tracking devices are directly electrically connected to an array of solar cells. A single maximum power tracking device is currently used 10 to control the available power from an array of between ten to several hundred cells. OBJECT OF THE INVENTION It is an object of the present invention to provide an alternate maximum power tracking device that overcomes at least in part one or more of the above mentioned 15 problems or disadvantages. SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION The present invention arises from the realization that each cell at any one particular time point will have a unique maximum power point defined by a specific 20 cell voltage and specific current at which the cell will produce its maximum available power. Furthermore the invention was developed from the realization that it is not possible for every cell in an array to operate at its maximum power point if the array is formed by the direct electrical interconnection of cells. With this in mind and taking advantage of recent advances in low voltage electronics, maximum power tracking WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -4 devices for very small groups of directly connected cells or for single solar cells were developed to provide a solution to optimizing the electrical power from the array. In one aspect the present invention broadly resides in a system for providing power from solar cells including 5 one or more solar generators wherein each of said solar generators has one to nine solar cells; a maximum power tracker operatively associated with each solar generator, each of said maximum power tracker includes a buck type DC/DC converter without an output inductor, each of said maximum power trackers are operatively connected 10 in series with each other; an inductor operatively connected to the series connected maximum power trackers; and means for providing electrical power from the inductor to load means, wherein each of said maximum power trackers is controlled so that the operatively associated 15 solar generator operates at its maximum power point to extract maximum available power. The maximum power tracker preferably includes an energy storage capacitor. and a control means for adjusting the buck type DC/DC converter duty cycle so that a connected solar generator operates at its maximum power point. 20 Preferably the control means makes observations of solar generator voltage, and observations of the change in energy storage capacitor voltage during the buck converter switch off time and observations of the duration of the buck converter switch off time to infer solar generator power to adjust the buck converter duty cycle to extract maximum power from the connected solar generator.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -5 In one preferred embodiment, the switching operations of the DC/DC converter are synchronized in frequency by the use of a synchronizing signal. Preferably each solar generator includes one solar cell. Preferably each solar generator includes one solar cell and each solar cell is connected to its own 5 dedicated maximum power tracker so that the tracker responds to its connected solar cell. Preferably the system uses a single inductor. Load means includes devices that use or store the electrical power. 10 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS In order that the present invention can be more readily understood and put into practical effect, reference will now be made to the accompanying drawings wherein: Figure 1 is a diagrammatic view of a simplified Buck type DC/DC converter 15 with solar generator and load; Figure 2 is a diagrammatic view of an alternative embodiment of a simplified Buck type DC/DC converter with solar generator and load; Figure 3 is a diagrammatic view of a solar generator with a Buck type DC/DC converter without an inductor; 20 Figure 4 is a diagrammatic view of an alternative embodiment of a solar generator with a Buck type DC/DC converter without an inductor; Figure 5 is a diagrammatic view of the interconnection of a plurality of Buck type DC/DC converters without inductors, corresponding plurality of solar generators, one inductor and a load; and WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -6 Figure 6 is a diagrammatic view of a preferred embodiment of the single cell MPPT converter; Figure 7 is a graphical representation of the control signals and gate signals for MOSFETs; 5 Figure 8 is a graphical representation of a no load 2kHz waveforms, top MOSFET gate waveform; top MOSFET gate drive referred to ground, bottom MOSFET gate waveform to ground, output terminal to ground (from top to bottom); Figure 9 is a graphical representation of an unloaded 20kHz waveforms, Traces top to bottom, output terminal, bottom MOSFET gate, top MOSFET gate, all 10 referred to ground; Figure 10 is a graphical representation of a loaded 20kHz waveforms, traces top to bottom, output terminal, bottom MOSFET gate, top MOSFET gate, all referred to ground; Figure 11 is a graphical representation of input voltage, current and power at 15 1 0kHz (from top to bottom); Figure 12 is a graphical representation of output current, voltage and power at 10kHz (from top to bottom); Figure 13 is a table of equipment for efficiency measurement; and Figure 14 is a table of converter efficiency at different frequencies. 20 DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT With reference to Figure 1 there is shown a simplified buck type DC/DC converter 10 connected to a solar generator 11 and load 12. The solar generator 11 can be a solar cell or several cells. The buck type DC/DC converter 10 includes a 25 capacitor 13 which serves as an energy storage element, a controlled switching WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -7 device 14, a diode or a controlled device acting as a synchronous rectifier 15 and an output inductor 16. An alternative arrangement for the buck type DC/DC converter 10 is shown in Figure 2. A buck type DC/DC converter can be controlled to operate the solar generator 5 at its maximum power point while producing an adjustable level of output current. The solar generator and maximum power tracker will be referred to as a solar generator /MPPT. Many solar generators/MPPT can be series connected. Each DC/DC converter will then have an identical output current but they can be individually controlled to allow each solar generator to operate at their maximum 10 power point. A conventional buck converter uses an output inductor to provide energy storage that is necessary for current filtering. An important feature of this invention is that the many inductors would normally be required, one for each solar generator/MPPT, and this can be replaced by a single inductor which will perform the 15 energy storage and filtering function for many series connected solar generator/MPPT. The MPPT device can be produced as an inductor free device. Figure 3 shows an inductorless DC/DC buck converter with a solar generator while Figure 4 shows an alternate embodiment. Many solar generators/MPPT devices that utilize inductor free DC/DC buck 20 converters can be series connected with a single inductor to supply power to an electrical load. The series connection of the solar generators/MPPT devices forces each inductorless DC/DC buck converter to supply an identical output current. Each converter operates with a constant current load. The controlled switching device operates alternates between an open and 25 closed state. The average portion of time that the switch is closed is the switch duty WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -8 cycle. Closure of the controlled switching device causes the load current to be supplied from the solar generator and the energy storage capacitor. When the controlled switch is open, the load current transfers to the diode or synchronous rectifier device while the solar generator current replenishes the charge within 5 energy storage capacitor. The duty cycle of the controlled switching device will determine the average current withdrawn from the energy storage capacitor. The energy storage capacitor will adjust its voltage in response to the difference in the current supplied by the solar generator and the current withdrawn to by the controlled switch. The switching 10 device will be controlled by a device that adjusts the controlled switch duty cycle to maintain the solar generator voltage at the maximum power point. With respect to Figure 5 there is shown a solar generator 20 connected to a capacitor 21, diode 22 and control switch 23. The capacitor 21, diode 22 and control switch 23 forms the inductorless DC/DC converter 24. Several solar generators 20 15 are connected in series via their dedicated inductorless DC/DC converters 24. Each solar generator 20 has its own inductorless DC/DC converters 24. After the last inductorless DC/DC converters 24, there is an inductor 25 to filter the current prior to reaching the load 26. The inductor 25 can be smaller in terms of magnetic energy shortage measured as LI 2 ,where L is the inductance value in Henry and I is the 20 inductor current, in Amperes, than the total combined set of inductors that are normally used with each buck DC/DC converter. The use of a smaller inductor and only one inductor reduces cost and weight and increases the efficiency in providing maximum power from the solar cells. In the preferred embodiment the solar generator consists of a solar generator which is a single high performance solar cell.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -9 With reference to Figure 6, there is shown a DC to DC converter 30 in the formed by MOSFETs Q1 and Q2 (31 and 32 respectively), and the energy storage capacitor 33. No filter inductor is required. In this preferred embodiment MOSFET Q1 (31) is a synchronous rectifier implementation of the diode device and MOSFET 5 Q2 (32) is the buck converter controlled switch element. In the preferred embodiment the output terminals of the solar generator/MPPT device are the the drain terminal of Q1, point X and the junction of the source terminal of Q1 and the drain terminal of Q2, point Y. The control element of the maximum power device is a microprocessor. In 10 this preferred embodiment, an ultra-low power Texas Instruments MSP430 microprocessor 34 which is capable of operation at a supply voltage of 1.8V. This allows direct operation from a dual junction cell which typically produces 2V. If other cell types are used with lower cell voltages, a power conditioning device may be required to develop a higher voltage supply to allow the control element to be 15 operated from a single cell. For example, silicon cells typically produce 0.4V and a voltage boosting converter would be required to generate a voltage high enough to operate a microprocessor control element. An alternate embodiment is possible where the solar generator/MPPT device output terminals are the junction of Q1 and Q2, point Y, and the source of Q2. In this 20 case Q1 is the controlled switch element and Q2 is the diode element implemented as a synchronous rectifier. The gate drive voltage for the MOSFETS Q1 and Q2 is derived by charge pump circuit. In the preferred implementation a multiple stage charge pump circuit formed by diodes D 1 to D 4 , devices 35-38, and their associated capacitors 39-42.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -10 The MOSFETS Q1 and Q2 are driven by a gate driver circuit. In the preferred embodiment a comparator, 43, forms the driver circuit. As this circuit delivers a higher gate to source voltage to device Q2 than Q1, Q2 achieves a lower turn on resistance. In the preferred embodiment Q2 is the controlled switching device as 5 this arrangement minimises power losses. Resistors 44 and 45 form a voltage divider network which is used to perform voltage observations of solar generator voltage using a analogue to digital converter within the microprocessor 34. An important feature of the maximum power tracking method is the measurement of cell voltage magnitude, the and measurement of the 10 change in cell voltage during periods when the controlled switch, 32, is open and the measurement of the time that the controlled switch is open to infer cell power. This may be used as an input to a maximum power tracking method that will control the DC-DC converter duty cycle to allow the solar generator to operate at maximum power. 15 In order to secure high efficiency in the solar generator/MPPT, low switching frequencies are preferred. In the preferred embodiment switching frequencies will be below 20 kHz. At very low switching frequencies the ripple voltage on capacitor C1 will increase. The voltage ripple will cause the cell to deviate from its maximum power point. An optimum switching frequency range will exist. In the preferred 20 embodiments the switching frequency will be adjusted to maximise the energy delivered by the solar generator/MPPT. A plurality of solar generator/MPPT may be configured within a large array to switch at the same frequency and with a relative phase relationship that provides improved cancellation of switching frequency voltage components in the output 25 voltage waveforms of the solar generator/MPPT combinations. This allows a smaller WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 - 11 inductor to provide filtering of the load current. Such synchronisation may be provided by auxiliary timing signals that are distributed within an array or by other means. In some embodiments the solar generator/MPPT devices within an array may 5 not switch at the same frequency. The combined output voltage of large number of asynchronously switching series connected buck converters will follow a binomial distribution. The average output voltage of the group of n solar generator/MPPT devices, with an input voltage Vi, and a duty cycle d, increases linearly with n while the switching ripple or the distortion voltage, Vdist, rises as 4n. 10 Vdist=Vin n(d-d 2 ) (1) Likewise the average volt second area, A, for a shared filter inductor follows an In relationship. 15 A =[n (d -d2) (2) f In a non synchronized embodiment, a larger inductor is required than in an optimally synchronized embodiment. The required inductor is still significantly 20 smaller than the combined plurality of inductors that would be required for conventional buck converters. A prototype converter was developed to first examine the conversion efficiency of the DC to DC converter stage and its suitability for use with a dual junction single solar cell, with an approximate maximum power point at 2V and WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 -12 300mA. For these tests the MSP340 was programmed to drive the charge pump circuitry and to operate the buck converter stage at a fixed 50% duty ratio. The experimental circuit is as in Figure 6. A fixed 2V input source voltage was applied and a load consisting of a 2 500ptH inductor and a 1.6 C resistor was applied. A 5 dead-time of 0.8pS is inserted in each turn-on and turn-off transient to prevent MOSFETs shoot through conduction events. As gate charging loss was a significant loss contributor, a range of operating frequencies was trialled. Figure 7 shows the control waveforms at 20kHz. The waveforms show the dead times between the top and bottom signals at turn-on and 10 turn-off. All waveforms in this figure are ground referred. The measured no load loss in this condition was 6mW which is approximately twice the expected figure. The gate drive loss is fully developed at no load and we may have additional loss in the charge pump circuitry. Figure 8 shows gate waveforms at 2kHz but a differential measurement is made of Vgsi to show the lowering of the gate source voltage to 15 approximately 4V due to elevation of the source at the device turn-on. The waveforms at 20 kHz without load are shown in Figure 9. Note that the load connection is across terminals X and Y. The lower MOSFET has the higher gate drive voltage and a lower Rdson. Figure 10 shows the loaded waveforms. Note the conduction of the MOSFET inverse diodes in the dead time as seen by the 2 pS 20 wide peaks on the leading and trailing pulse top edges on the top trace. The transfer of current to these diodes generates an additional conduction loss of 24mW which reduces efficiency at higher frequencies. Given circuit losses are around a few percentage points of rating, precise voltage and current measurements are needed if power measurements are used to 25 determine efficiency. A complication is that the output is inductorless and both the WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 - 13 output voltage and current contain significant switching frequency components. It is likely that a significant amount of power is transferred to the combined R-L load at frequencies other than DC. In order to determine the efficiency of this converter, a new high end 5 oscilloscope was used to measure the input and output power. The internal math function was employed to obtain the instantaneous power from the current and voltage, the mean value of which indicates the average power. The current probe was carefully calibrated before each current measurement, to minimise measurement errors. Figure 13 shows the details of the equipment used in a table 10 format. Figures 11 and 12 show the input and output voltages, current and power. The mean value of measured power is displayed at the right column of the figures. The efficiencies of the converter obtained are shown in a table in Figure 14. It is seen that the measured efficiency is slightly lower than estimated especially at higher frequencies. One reason is the loss during the dead-time. The on-state 15 voltage drop of the diode is much higher than the MOSFET, and therefore reduces the efficiency of the converter. At 10kHz the dead time loss accounts for 12mW of the observed 30mW. The results do confirm that the circuit is capable of achieving high efficiencies especially if the switching frequency is low. 20 VARIATIONS It will of course be realised that while the foregoing has been given by way of illustrative example of this invention, all such and other modifications and variations thereto as would be apparent to persons skilled in the art are deemed to fall within the broad scope and ambit of this invention as is herein set forth.

WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 - 14 Throughout the description and claims this specification the word "comprise" and variations of that word such as "comprises" and "comprising", are not intended to exclude other additives, components, integers or steps.

Claims

1. A system for providing power from solar cells including one or more solar generators wherein each of said solar generators has one to nine solar cells; 5 a maximum power tracker operatively associated with each solar generator, each of said maximum power tracker includes a buck type DC/DC converter without an output inductor, each of said maximum power trackers are operatively connected in series with each other; an inductor operatively connected to the series connected maximum power 10 trackers; and means for providing electrical power from the inductor to load means, wherein each of said maximum power trackers is controlled so that the operatively associated solar generator operates at its maximum power point to extract maximum available power. 15

2. A system as claimed in claim 1 wherein the maximum power tracker includes an energy storage capacitor and a control means for adjusting the buck type DC/DC converter duty cycle so that a connected solar generator operates at its maximum power point. 20

3. A system as claimed in claim 1 wherein the maximum power tracker includes an energy storage capacitor and a control means for adjusting the buck type DC/DC converter duty cycle so that a connected solar generator operates at its maximum power point; said control means makes observations of solar generator voltage, and 25 observations of the change in energy storage capacitor voltage during the buck WO 2006/005125 PCT/AU2005/001017 - 16 converter switch off time and observations of the duration of the buck converter switch off time to infer solar generator power to adjust the buck converter duty cycle to extract maximum power from the connected solar generator. 5

4. A system as claimed in any one of the above mentioned claims wherein the switching operations of the DC/DC converter are synchronized in frequency by the use of a synchronizing signal.

5. A system as claimed in any one of the above mentioned claims wherein each 10 solar generator includes one solar cell.

6. A system as claimed in any one of the above mentioned claims wherein each solar generator includes one solar cell and each solar cell is connected to its own dedicated maximum power tracker so that the tracker responds to its connected 15 solar cell.

7. A system as claimed in any one of the above mentioned claims wherein the system uses a single inductor. 20

8. A system as claimed in any one of the above mentioned claims wherein load means includes devices that use or store the electrical power.

9. A system as substantially described herein with reference to and as illustrated by the accompanying drawings. 25